Relationship: An Answer to the Adolescent Crisis
As a child, do you remember sitting in a church meeting and the teacher asking a question? Maybe a question like, “Who made the animals?” or “Who is always at church?” The “right” answer to the questions seemed to always be “Jesus” or “God.” The question could change, but the answer remained the same: Jesus! Yes, in one sense and as an answer to certain questions, Jesus is the answer, as the old Andrae Crouch song aptly claims. I believe Jesus transforms hearts and lives for His glory. But I want to suggest an item that youth ministries could advocate with the students God has given us the opportunity to impact. The item is so obvious but stifled by some and unintentionally ignored by others in youth ministry.
The Crisis Facing Today’s Teenagers
The latest research concerning the current generation (Z or iGen nomenclature) offers explosive data. Jean Twenge in iGen, Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff in Coddling of the American Mind, and Jonathan Haidt in his book The Anxious Generation provide thousands of pages of data and observations of teenagers from the past and in the present. They assert that technology and devices are king, and the lack of playtime for children and person-to-person contact in both children and youth have created isolation and deficient social skills. Two key issues now exist among teenagers: mental health crisis and device addiction. The COVID-19 pandemic greatly enabled these problems to expand.
The mental health crisis among teenagers is enormous. Depression and suicide rates have been elevated in recent years. The idol worship level of technological devices (iPhone in particular) has led to adolescent issues. Students don’t know how to function in a community, have a conversation, or perform in a one-on-one job interview. But they are very capable of hiding behind the words they create on a device for good or evil. A disconnect with person-to-person relationships seems apparent. The increase in depression, suicide, and loneliness among teenagers implies a need for relationships.
Where I Was Inspired
In 1996, I attended a youth ministry conference in Atlanta, Georgia, at the Georgia Dome. It included a who’s who list of youth ministry speakers and Contemporary Christian Music (CCM) artists. Thousands of youth workers from around the country attended, representing a plethora of denominations. Each speaker was allotted fifteen minutes. Dawson McAllister was a youth ministry guru from the 1980s until his death in 2020. He spoke in one of the time slots. During his fifteen minutes, he said something that I found to be timely and true, and I agreed with his observation. He said that when he started in youth ministry, youth ministers were challenged to save students, teach students, and send students to reach others. He said, “Today, we have to save them, heal them, teach them, and send them.” Every youth ministry conference I attended in that era dealt with dysfunctional families and students. Mental health issues were elevated to new levels of importance for youth ministers. The correlation for me is that today, we might have the same scenario, and thus, an opportunity for healing is needed among teenagers.
The Power Of Relationships
How can we heal them? How can we overcome the lack of social skills in community due to technology addiction? How can we battle the depression and suicide numbers among teenagers? There is a time when a professional is needed, and we must refer a student for help. I want to suggest one item for those in the daily trenches of youth ministry. By no means is this the only answer, like “Jesus” was the only answer as a child. Your experience and context may offer other helpful suggestions. A relationship is the one potential solution I want to suggest.
The depth and severity of the issues for some teenagers do need professional help, and we in youth ministry must point those families and students in the proper direction. We are spiritual counselors, not professional counselors. Our position enables us to serve as a part of the solution. The spiritual counsel we offer must aim at having an impact, or better stated, producing life change. The opportunity we have in daily church youth ministry is to impact youth through three different levels of relationships.
Three Levels Of Relationships
The first is impress. This does not require an established relationship. If Michael Jordan walks into my office, I am impressed, and no relationship is required. An example of this level is talking with students before or after the morning church worship. Another example is during or after the meet-and-greet time of the weekly youth group meeting. This is an opportunity to impress students and create a comfort-level relationship. The second is influence. This level requires some relationship. A group of students and you are talking about where to eat after the youth meeting, and you use your influence to suggest a certain burger place. Or you spend all day with students at a theme park riding rides, swimming, eating, taking pics, and making reels, which creates an opportunity for influence. A minimal level of relationship is required and can open the door for a more in-depth relationship in the future.
Another example of influence could be the apparent most popular method of discipleship currently employed by youth ministers. This example is the fifteen-minute talkback/discussion time with a small group of students after the youth minister speaks/teaches. Minimal relationships are needed, and minimal relationships are the deepest level allowed by the short amount of time. An in-depth or close relationship is not possible during such a limited time. But, from anecdotal observation, youth minister conversations, and my students’ research with class assignments, this is currently the most popular youth ministry method of discipleship. The achievement of relational depth is limited and unlikely.
I want to suggest that the third level of relationship, which is impact, serves as the best option for addressing the aforementioned issues with teenagers and serves as a more conducive discipleship process. More time spent with fewer people produces greater results in ministry. The result is that life change, or the likelihood of looking more like Jesus (Romans 8:29), becomes stronger with life-on-life discipleship that includes accountability for a longer period. The process of discipleship should result in life change, which should be the goal.
A Call To Stay And Invest
An emphasis on relationship building in youth ministry sounds like an oxymoron statement. “I thought we were already doing that?” might be someone’s thought. The difference is closer relationships with fewer people by more adults from the body of Christ (church) who invest deeply into a few students. This problem cannot be solved by settling for getting students to show up, filling the calendar with events, attractional events, emotionally driven programs, a cool youth room, and band, or any other popular youth ministry assumption of healthy youth ministry. The problem is real and deep. Therefore, a deeper response is needed. Investment through relationship building takes time. Building trust in a relationship takes time.
The subplot here is for you to stay longer for deeper investment. Let’s build deep relationships that aid in curbing this crisis of suicide, depression, and technological idol worship. May we delete the unintentional ignoring of the importance of deep relationships with students by using methods that expect impact? May we not stifle the importance of relationships and life investment with fluffy and weak programming. May we join with the Holy Spirit to see students become holistically healthy men and women of God.
Share your thoughts with others in our YM360 community:
- In what ways can you be more intentional about building deep, impactful relationships with the families in your ministry?
- Do you think there is a temptation to build relationships on an impress level? If so, why? Lastly, why will the impress level not bring about the same type of change as impact?
Leave a comment